When Esther Carruthers realizes her father had been embezzling from her fiancé's father's bank, she doesn't expect her life to change. After her fiancé immediately ends the engagement, she is shocked and dismayed. Her younger sister—the thinker in the family—convinces her to talk to a matchmaker, and she immediately agrees to marry a rancher in Montana, somewhere she's never been, and no one knows her.
Brody Finnegan has worked hard for the past few years to build up his ranch in Montana. Everything is falling into place for him, and now it's time for him to send for a bride. When Esther steps off the train, he is mesmerized by her, and she's everything he dreamed she would be. The shock comes when he finds out she brought her younger sister along. Will the two of them be able to get past her deception? Or will their marriage be over before it has a chance to start?